Text Me Maybe & Two-Person Problem
Have you ever felt your heart sink when a text conversation goes sideways?
Do you find yourself staring at your screen, trying to decode what someone really meant, wondering if a simple phone call could have prevented the whole mess?
The truth is, how we communicate has fundamentally changed, and most of us are still figuring out how to navigate it.
Text-based communication has become our default, but it’s stripping away the context, tone, and connection that make real understanding possible.
And when you’re trying to build something meaningful with someone who communicates completely differently than you do? It doesn’t just create frustration. It creates distance, which our listener, Angie, learned the hard way:
“I’m seeing this guy and we have totally different ways of communicating and it’s starting to become a problem. He’s all about texting, like everything is through text with him. He wants to have these deep conversations over text and I’m more of a ‘can we just call, can we actually talk?’ person. Last week I had something I really needed to bring up with him and I texted him about it since that’s what he prefers and it went so wrong. Do you think different communication styles can actually work, or am I just fighting a losing battle here?”
If you’ve ever compromised how you naturally communicate to accommodate someone else, only to watch it backfire, you’re not alone. And no, this isn’t necessarily a sign you’re incompatible. But it is a sign that something needs to shift.
(2:00) The Texting Trap Is Real
Here’s something that might surprise you: texting has disrupted relationships MORE than dating apps ever did. Everyone loves to blame swiping for why we can’t connect anymore.
But the real problem?
- 70% of our communication today happens through typed words, and our brains literally haven’t caught up. We’re all walking around confused and frustrated because of it.
When you communicate over text, it strips away all of the context that we learned in how to communicate when we were younger.
If you didn’t grow up glued to a phone, learning to communicate through text feels like trying to speak a language you never studied. And even if you did grow up texting, it still can’t capture tone, facial expressions, or those crucial pauses that tell you what someone actually means.
We’re not mad that texting exists. We’re mad because we keep trying to have serious, vulnerable conversations through screens the size of our palms, then wonder why we keep misunderstanding each other.
(9:00) Why They Love Texting (And It’s Not What You Think)
Before you decide someone’s texting habit is a red flag, get curious about what’s actually going on.
Some people text because they need time to think. Real-time conversation feels like getting ambushed. They’re worried they’ll say something wrong, and their brain works slower than their mouth needs to move.
Other reasons someone might prefer texting:
- It feels safer – Especially for introverts. Texting provides a buffer of intimacy in digital communication to help them access their feelings more.
- It’s about efficiency – Maybe they have a lot of pressures at work and can’t process everything right now. Texting lets them do it on their own time.
- They’re avoiding something – Maybe they’re avoiding vulnerability that will come out in a real-time conversation. They don’t have to sit with uncomfortable silence, see your immediate reaction, or be fully present in the moment.
Figuring out why someone prefers texting doesn’t mean you just have to live with it forever. But it does help you understand what you’re actually working with.
(14:00) The Compatibility vs. Concession Question
Communication style matters. Like, really matters. But it’s not automatically a dealbreaker if you’re both willing to adjust.
Here’s where people panic: they hit one bump and immediately think, “This is it. We’re not compatible. It’s over.” But what if this friction is actually useful?
Compatibility is not about being the same. It’s about being able to bridge the gap.
Real compatibility means both people can flex. But here’s what actually matters: if you’re the only one bending, that’s not compatibility. That’s you making all the sacrifices while they stay comfortable. And that builds resentment faster than you think.
The questions to ask:
- Is your partner willing to stretch the way you’re stretching for them?
- Have they even been given the opportunity to do that?
Because in this case, there was texting when calling was needed. The question is, would they call when you needed to talk on the phone?
(18:00) How to Have “The Talk” About Talking
You can’t fix this by yourself. You need to actually talk about how you’re going to talk going forward.
And yeah, this conversation needs to happen in person —not as punishment, not as some power move —but because it’s too important to risk screwing up again.
Here’s the framework:
- Start by setting the stage: Give him a heads-up that you need to talk without blindsiding him or making him dread the conversation.
- Then name what happened: Acknowledge what went wrong, validate his preference, then ask how you can meet in the middle.
- And then pause: See how he responds—does he get defensive, dismiss your needs, or actually hear you and try to find a solution?
Give them space to respond before you jump in with solutions.
Maybe you’ll find out your calls wreck their work flow. Maybe they just need time to process before they talk. You won’t know until you ask.
(24:00) Finding Your Communication Code
This isn’t a wall. It’s a door you both need to figure out how to open.
Think about all of these skills as life skills that you can then take into your next relationship or your work.
Two-person problem, two-person solution. You figure it out together. Can different communication styles work? Sure. But only if you’re both willing to move.
If they care about you and this relationship, they will meet you halfway or three-quarters of the way, or a quarter of the way, or just somewhere along the road.
And if they won’t budge? Then you’re not losing anything. You’re learning who they are and whether that actually fits your life.
The point isn’t to change each other. It’s to find a way to connect that doesn’t require either of you to disappear.
Communication problems don’t mean you picked the wrong person.
They mean you have a chance to build something that actually works. If you’re both willing to listen, adjust, and care about what the other person needs, you’re not stuck. You’re learning how to love someone in a way that’s real. And that matters.
💌 Got a communication question you’ve been sitting on?
Whether it’s about dating, relationships, boundaries, or what the heck to text back, we’re here for all of it.
Send your question in a DM or voice memo on Instagram, TikTok, or Facebook, or send a voicemail or text to 424-246-6255. It might just be featured in an upcoming Dear Damona segment.
And remember: Dates & Mates isn’t just about romantic relationships anymore. It’s about the people who matter most: partners, friends, family, and you.
📝 Want to keep track of what’s working (and what’s not) in your love life?
Download the free Date Tracker at damonahoffman.com/datetracker